Monday, November 26, 2007

Cease and Desist

I guess it was just a matter of time. I finally received a cease and desist letter from Wizards of the Coast legal counsel. They said I violated their copyright. I didn't know Wizards copyrighted all of their card names, but maybe they do. I presume they don't copyright the rules but I'm not clear on that point. Just wanted to tell everyone.


My name is Jacob Moorman; I am the Director of Operations for You are receiving this mail because you are the
project administrator of the 'mtgforge' project, hosted by you on We have recently received the following (forwarded)
DMCA request from the complainant (CC'd).

When cases like this arise, we always expeditiously forward the mail to
the project admin. Please review this message carefully and follow-up
as needed.

Following the DMCA requirements we have disabled public access to the space provided to your project.

You can read the specifics about our DMCA compliance in our Terms and
Conditions of Use page:

You can read our DMCA policy, including instructions for
counter-notification at:

Thank you for your prompt attention to this serious matter.


Jacob Moorman

CC: SourceForge legal
CC: Savvis ( datacenter provider)

Begin forwarded message:

> *From: *" "
> >
> *Date: *November 16, 2007 11:47:17 AM GMT-05:00
> *To: *>, > >, > >, >
> *Cc: *" "
> >
> *Subject: **Sourceforge - Savvis Case 1152152 - DMCA Notice -
> -*
> Dear Administrator:
> SAVVIS has received notice that an IP address (see below) under your
> administrative control is distributing copyrighted works in violation

> of United States law, specifically, 17USC512 et seq., also known as
> the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA").
> Please note that this activity is both illegal and in violation of
> SAVVIS Acceptable Use Policy ("AUP"), a copy of which may be reviewed

> at
> Be advised that the DMCA places very stringent requirements on
> as the upstream provider, and that failure to resolve this issue in a

> timely manner could result in the termination of services to
> IP's or sites. SAVVIS follows the DMCA time requirements very
> strictly: this issue must be resolved within 7 days of this notice to

> avoid active intervention under DMCA.
> If you require any assistance in resolving this, or any other SAVVIS
> security issue, please do not hesitate to contact me at any of the
> below points of contact.
> Sincerely,
> Jason R. Bradley GSEC
> Security/Abuse Engineer
> SAVVIS Security Services (S3)
> SAVVIS Communications
> 1 Savvis Parkway
> St. Louis, MO 63017
> 314-628-7821 - Desk
> 314.628.7050 - Fax
> **This message contains information which may be confidential and/or
> privileged. Unless you are the intended recipient (or authorized to
> receive for the intended recipient), you may not read, use, copy or
> disclose to anyone the message or any information contained in the
> message. If you have received the message in error, please advise the

> sender by reply e-mail at
> and delete the message and any
> attachment(s) thereto without retaining any copies.**
> ************ORIGINAL COMPLAINT(S) BELOW*************
> *From:* Reynolds, Carin []
> *Sent:* Friday, November 16, 2007 10:01 AM
> *To:*
> *Subject:* DMCA Notice -
> November 16, 2007
> *_By Email_*
> DMCA Designated Agent
> SAVVIS Communications Corporation
> One SAVVIS Parkway
> Town & Country, Missouri 63017
> *Re: DMCA Notice – ***
> *_Infringement of Wizards of the Coast, Inc. Copyrights and
> Dear Copyright Agent:
> We are counsel for Wizards of the Coast, Inc. (“Wizards”), the
> of the copyrights and trademarks to the MAGIC: THE GATHERING®
> card game. We recently became aware that you are the service
> for , which has
> an online version of Wizards’ MAGIC: THE GATHERING® trading card
> at “MTG Forge”
> is a commonly used acronym for MAGIC: THE GATHERING®). The “MTG
> Forge” game is described as “a robust Java implementation of card
> Magic The Gathering that enforces the rules.” We have attempted
> repeatedly to contact the owner of this site, but have received no
> response and the infringing game has not yet been removed.
> This unauthorized copying of Wizards’ MAGIC: THE GATHERING®
> card game constitutes copyright infringement in violation of 17
> § 501. The unauthorized use of the MAGIC: THE GATHERING® name
> violates the federal trademark laws, including 15 U.S.C. §§ 1114(1)

> and 1125(a), by creating a likelihood of confusion with respect to
> Wizards’ authorization or sponsorship of or association with the
> Forge” trading card game and the website. This
> unauthorized use of the MAGIC: THE GATHERING® trademark is also
> to dilute its distinctive quality in violation of 15 U.S.C. §
> and the anti-dilution laws of numerous states.
> Pursuant to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (“DMCA”), we
have a
> good faith belief that the “MTG Forge” game identified above
> Wizard’s copyrights and other intellectual property rights, and is
> authorized by Wizards or its agents. We are authorized to act on
> Wizards’ behalf regarding these matters. The information provided
> this communication is accurate to the best of my knowledge and is
> provided under penalty of perjury.
> On behalf of Wizards, we therefore request that you act promptly to
> remove or disable access to the infringing “MTG Forge” game from
> website*.*
> This letter does not purport to be a complete statement of the facts
> or the law and is without prejudice to Wizards’ legal and equitable

> rights.
> Sincerely yours,
> Carin G. Reynolds, Esq.
> *Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP*
> 1133 Avenue of the Americas
> New York, NY 10036-6710
> /tel/: 212.336.2104
> /fax/: 212.336.2277
> ----------------------------------------------
> Privileged/Confidential Information may be contained in this message.
If you are not
> the addressee indicated in this message (or responsible for delivery
of the message to
> such person), you may not copy or deliver this message to anyone. In
such case, you
> should destroy this message and kindly notify the sender by reply
email. Please advise
> immediately if you or your employer do not consent to Internet email
for messages of this
> kind.
> ----------------------------------------------
> IRS Circular 230 disclosure: Any tax advice contained in this
communication (including
> any attachments or enclosures) was not intended or written to be
used, and cannot be
> used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal
Revenue Code or (ii)
> promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction
or matter addressed
> in this communication. (The foregoing disclaimer has been affixed
pursuant to U.S.
> Treasury regulations governing tax practitioners.)
> This message contains information which may be confidential and/or
> privileged. Unless you are the intended recipient (or authorized to
> receive for the intended recipient), you may not read, use, copy or
> disclose to anyone the message or any information contained in the
> message. If you have received the message in error, please advise the

> sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachment(s)
> thereto without retaining any copies.

Jacob Moorman
Director of Operations,

This email may contain confidential and privileged material for the
use of the intended recipient. Any review or distribution by others is
strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,
please contact the sender and delete all copies.


moprix said...

it was bound to happen.

Thanks for the work you put in.

I am interested in programming some AI for card games. If this is up your alley (and it seems to be) write me.

Anonymous said...

I don't think the names are copyrighted but the card pictures are.

Anonymous said...

WotC legal deparment has always been made up of trigger-happy little bastards. So it should only take a talk with a representiive to clear anything up.

Might even get someone in trouble. :D

Anonymous said...

Damn man, it sucks >_<

Unknown said...

I see that you have already removed your project from Source Forge... ;_; It must be a sad day for you, and for all the users of your program... >_<

Any idea why they tell you to put an end to your project, whereas some other projects aren't shut down? (e.g. Magic-Project, now known as Firemox...)

Anyway, I hope what chojiro says is true, and maybe you will find a way to continue the development of your program. At least, it's worth a try, isn't it? :)

I tried MTGForge recently and I must say you did a very good job! Although the user interface could be more "practical", the game is fun to play and the AI is decent.

I'm also working on an implementation of Magic (I started a few weeks ago, so it's really the early stages of development.). I'm not planning on making it public though (at least not any time soon), I mainly do this as a "challenge" because MTG is a great and interesting game and I wanna see if I'm able to program a game with such complicated rules. I guess it was one of your motivations, too? :)

Many years ago, I used to play Microprose's Magic game for PC (Shandalar...) and I loved it. I've always been interested in the Artificial Intelligence that they managed to develop. It wasn't nearly as good as a real player, but it was still challenging and good enough to make the game quite fun - and it's all that matters.

Anyway, like Moprix, I'm also interested in discussion about AI, if you have some time to waste :)

Nanocore said...

Unfortunately, I am not surprised at all. While you have to pull this from the net, what you did put out there is a good base in case someone wanted to make their own "for personal use". That is, unless they said stop all development completely and absolutely no development what so ever. Was this how it was worded?